Q – Coach, I’ve noticed a lot of hockey players in the NHL are inhaling smelling salts before the start of games. Just wondering if they might be good for distance runners. I haven’t seen any of the elite runners at the big marathons using, but just wondering what your opinion is.
A – Funny you asked this because last night I particularly noticed the super rookie Leaf player, Auston Matthews, taking a whiff of the salts. BTW, Leafs lost the game to Columbus….
First, let’s be clear of what we’re discussing.
Smelling salts, also referred to as ammonia inhalants can come in packets about the size of small tootsie rolls. The usual active compound is ammonium carbonate and when released causes the muscles that control breathing to work faster.
A – Funny you asked this because last night I particularly noticed the super rookie Leaf player, Auston Matthews, taking a whiff of the salts. BTW, Leafs lost the game to Columbus….
First, let’s be clear of what we’re discussing.
Smelling salts, also referred to as ammonia inhalants can come in packets about the size of small tootsie rolls. The usual active compound is ammonium carbonate and when released causes the muscles that control breathing to work faster.
Vial of Smelling Salts
Traditionally they've used to revive consciousness after fainting or on boxers,. But this is no longer recommended and in many sports is banned because it may inhibit or delay a proper and thorough neurological assessment by a healthcare professional
Use by Hockey Players
The subject of it’s fairly common usage by NHL hockey players has certainly been publicized in the print.
In March 2016 there was a Sports Illustrated article (see here). And in 2014, the New England Sports Network (NESN) published a very funny article that included a GIF showing Phil Kessel’s reaction to inhaling the product (here).
Use by Hockey Players
The subject of it’s fairly common usage by NHL hockey players has certainly been publicized in the print.
In March 2016 there was a Sports Illustrated article (see here). And in 2014, the New England Sports Network (NESN) published a very funny article that included a GIF showing Phil Kessel’s reaction to inhaling the product (here).
Phil Kessel reacts to a whiff
The author of the SI article, which included comments from some of the players and a coach summed it up: “So, at most, it provides a temporary boost and perhaps a slightly longer placebo effect, depending on the individual.
Coyotes veteran Shane Doan, who, according to the article, says he hasn’t used them in three years, compared the experience to a quick window wipe at the gas pump, flushing out eyes weary from the road or the rink’s fluorescent lights.”
Use by Runners ?
You"ll often see track sprinters slapping themselves on the legs or face before the start of a race, with the aim of arousing themselves for the very intense effort ahead; but I've never seen a sprinter use smelling salts in the final moments before going to the blocks.
One might think that sprinters would be apt to employ the salts but then it’s very important for the sprinter to be calmly focusing on responding to the starter’s instructions and reacting to the gun; so taking a whiff of salts just before going to the blocks might risk undermining this process.
And as for the long distance runners, there's a huge difference between a hockey player's 40 second shift and a 40+ km. marathon lasting hours.That you haven’t seen any of the top marathoners imbibe is a strong indicator that the salts are not deemed to enhance performance. After all, as has been demonstrated coaches and athletes are forever exploring anything that might give an edge. Besides, the last thing you want to do is get over aroused risking too fast a pace in the beginning.
In fact, the only item I’ve come across is some lay speculation that the woman’s gold medalist in the 2008 Bejiing Olympic Marathon, Constantina Tomescu-Dita, of Romania, at age 38, may have inhaled smelling salts in the latter stages of the marathon (see here), but I haven’t seen any verification for this. BTW, it's not and illegal substance.
Coyotes veteran Shane Doan, who, according to the article, says he hasn’t used them in three years, compared the experience to a quick window wipe at the gas pump, flushing out eyes weary from the road or the rink’s fluorescent lights.”
Use by Runners ?
You"ll often see track sprinters slapping themselves on the legs or face before the start of a race, with the aim of arousing themselves for the very intense effort ahead; but I've never seen a sprinter use smelling salts in the final moments before going to the blocks.
One might think that sprinters would be apt to employ the salts but then it’s very important for the sprinter to be calmly focusing on responding to the starter’s instructions and reacting to the gun; so taking a whiff of salts just before going to the blocks might risk undermining this process.
And as for the long distance runners, there's a huge difference between a hockey player's 40 second shift and a 40+ km. marathon lasting hours.That you haven’t seen any of the top marathoners imbibe is a strong indicator that the salts are not deemed to enhance performance. After all, as has been demonstrated coaches and athletes are forever exploring anything that might give an edge. Besides, the last thing you want to do is get over aroused risking too fast a pace in the beginning.
In fact, the only item I’ve come across is some lay speculation that the woman’s gold medalist in the 2008 Bejiing Olympic Marathon, Constantina Tomescu-Dita, of Romania, at age 38, may have inhaled smelling salts in the latter stages of the marathon (see here), but I haven’t seen any verification for this. BTW, it's not and illegal substance.
Constantina Tomescu-Dita
Scientific Evidence
I’ve scoured the scientific literature and I’ve only come across two recent studies on this topic:
The first is a student’s Master thesis study conducted with young (early 20s) men and women at Old Dominion University, in Norfolk, Virginia, entitled,
The effects of pre-maximal exertion inhalation of ammonia and the performance effects during deadlift maximal tests (abstract here).
And the conclusion was that within the limitations of this study, there is no basis for the support of ammonia inhalation to improve 1-RM efforts in training, competition, or any other circumstance.
I’ve scoured the scientific literature and I’ve only come across two recent studies on this topic:
The first is a student’s Master thesis study conducted with young (early 20s) men and women at Old Dominion University, in Norfolk, Virginia, entitled,
The effects of pre-maximal exertion inhalation of ammonia and the performance effects during deadlift maximal tests (abstract here).
And the conclusion was that within the limitations of this study, there is no basis for the support of ammonia inhalation to improve 1-RM efforts in training, competition, or any other circumstance.
Deadlift
The second study was in New Zealand entitled,
Cerebrovascular, cardiovascular and strength responses to acute ammonia inhalation (abstract here) .
Fifteen healthy males completed two trials.Trial one investigated cerebral artery blood flow velocity, heart rate and arterial pressure response to ammonia inhalation. During trial two, participants performed a maximal single mid-thigh pull (MTP) .
Cerebrovascular, cardiovascular and strength responses to acute ammonia inhalation (abstract here) .
Fifteen healthy males completed two trials.Trial one investigated cerebral artery blood flow velocity, heart rate and arterial pressure response to ammonia inhalation. During trial two, participants performed a maximal single mid-thigh pull (MTP) .
Mid-thigh Pull
Despite the marked cerebrovascular and cardiovascular response to ammonia inhalation no ergogenic effect was observed during the MTP, irrespective of the timing of administration.
Given all this, I have to give the idea of distance runners using using smelling salts a...
RSS Feed
